• Megadeth and Iron Maiden—Live in Sydney 15/11

    Megadeth and Iron Maiden—Live in Sydney 15/11

    Megadeth and Iron Maiden performed in Sydney on the 15th.

    I arrived at Moore Park at 5:30pm, so I could enjoy all usual pre-show experiences. These include “paying $14 for a cup of Hahn SuperDry” and “wandering around the stadium six times because I thought Gate A was Gate 1” and “staring at sound wedges suspended a hundred feet in the air, wondering what happens if they forget to plug one in and if anyone gets fired when that happens.”

    The 42,500 capacity Allianz Stadium is a huge metal, glass and stucco exclusion zone, shaped like a football and sized like a suburb. While smaller than the 115,000 capacity Accor Stadium (which Taylor Swift sold out during the Eras Tour), it’s still sufficiently huge that the queues are so long you cannot see what you’re queuing for. It’s like playing a lootbox game where your prize might be a bathroom or some food or the show you paid to see. Feeling lucky? Get in the queue.

    (Or maybe everything was signposted and I’m blind. I do remember staring at a sign that seemed to read “we do not serve alcohol to minions”. Fair, those yellow tic-tac guys don’t look like they’d handle alcohol well.)

    It reminds me of queuing in Soviet countries. During the perestroika years, citizens would tend to join any queue they saw, because it meant a shop had something. “Get in the biggest queue you can find” is a surprisingly robust strategy.

    Then done was done. I took my place on the General Admission floor.

    it was time… for death. For a million deaths.

    Megadeth

    The crowd erupted as Dave Mustaine and company launched into “Hangar 18”. Mustaine’s shoulder-length hair is red, but when light shined down, it fluoresced to albino-white sheets. He looked like a vampire, clawing at his guitar.

    Megadeth used to be one of my favorite bands. I heard an AMV on Youtube with “99 Ways to Die” on it, and was amazed by how snarling and hateful the singer sounded. Like a cartoon character.

    Dave Mustaine is an intense person. I think he’s a genius, if a volatile and unstable one, and Megadeth is an extension of his fiery, self-destructive character. The band doesn’t sit still, second-guesses itself constantly, exists in a cycle of fracture, chaos, and reinvention, makes mistakes, and still occasionally hits gold. Megadeth’s many failures seem as necessary as its successes.

    Mustaine’s 1983 firing from Metallica is among metal’s most notorious origin stories and is likely remembered out of proportion to its significance. Mustaine had already matured as a guitarist and songwriter (he has claimed Metallica songs as late as “Leper Messiah” contain his writing), and it’s hard to imagine him staying in a band where he couldn’t rule the roost. I expect he would have left soon on his own.

    But yes, much of Megadeth’s career—the early Bay Area speed and aggression, the later genre-mixing, the commercial alt rock turn in the 1990s—could be read as him trying to outmuscle, outmaneuver, and outperform the band that had flung him out.. Kanye West is one of history’s most divorced men. Mustaine is among history’s most kicked-out. A sense of competition with Metallica (sometimes friendly, oftentimes not) permeates a lot of what he does.

    Yet, what defines Metallica? Their stability. Load or The Black Album (whatever you think of their musical quality) are works from a band that has chosen a direction and is following it to the end. Metallica is a massive oil tanker that needs six miles to turn.

    Megadeth is more like a raft lashed out of driftwood. Fast, nimble, but dangerous. The seas are stormy, the captain’s mad, the sextant long ago washed overboard, the crew is plotting mutiny. There’s a gripping sense of adventure—of “anything might happen”—to Megadeth’s chaotic story.

    In 45 years, just four people have left Metallica. One did so by dying. Another was Dave Mustaine, who could get kicked out of an empty room. In nearly the same period, Megadeth has had twenty-six members leave. The two bands are not the same.

    Though I remained a Megadeth fan, I drifted away in recent years. Their last few albums weren’t as good as I’d hoped, their best days appeared over, and Dave Mustaine’s ranting lyrics were starting to head in an Infowars direction (though the “Al-CIA-da” line in “Dance in the Rain” is hilarious.)

    I wasn’t aware that Megadeth’s latest album hit #1 in Australia. Luckily, Mustaine rectified my ignorance. “#1 in Australia, and in America!” he crowed, before launching into “Tipping Point”. I half expected him to pull up Wikipedia on his phone and prove it to us.

    Starting a show by bragging about your sales numbers is a very Dave Mustaine moment. I found it endearing. He cares extremely hard. He really, really wants to win. The correct amount of narcissism is not zero.

    Good on Dave—great that he finally achieved his dream!

    * * *

    The mix from the pit was pure dripping shit.

    Maybe our tightly-packed bodies absorbed sound. Maybe the sound engineer was a deep state operative, determined to stop Mustaine’s truth bombs from landing. But frankly, I couldn’t hear very well (or very much).

    The legendary Marty Friedman guitar solo on “Tornado of Souls” was audible as a tinnitus-like squeal. The iconic “Hangar 18” chord progression (Dm Bb Bdim C6/9) didn’t sound like a chord progression or even like music: it was an atonal din like a battleship sailing straight into an enormous angle-grinder. The sharp jugular-slash of “Holy War”‘s riff became fuzz. The cool Spanish flamenco segue to “…The Punishment Due” just…barely existed. It was like half the notes evaporated before reaching our ears.

    Megadeth is a band defined by blazingly technical guitar work. Mustaine has worked with some of the best axemen in the business (Marty Friedman, Chris Poland, Chris Broderick, Kiko Loureiro), and he’s skilled enough to shred right along with them. In this regard he clearly surpasses Metallica’s James Hetfield (who is a great rhythm player but capable of only basic lead work.) At times I felt like I was playing a “guess the Megadeth song” game based on loud/quiet dynamics.

    Unexpectedly, James LoMenzo’s bass proved the most comprehensible source of melody and structure, shining out of the murk like a lighthouse. The heavy swing and bounce of “Symphony of Destruction”‘s low end came through great, with a sea of bodies swaying along with it.

    Night came, and an ashen rain started to fall. The overhead lights shined through a galaxy of falling raindrops. Mustaine’s wry “…and now for a song about the weather!” got a laugh. (“Tornado of Souls”, you brainlet.)

    This set had to wear many hats. It was Megadeth’s “farewell” tour. A closing of the book, representing the scope of their history and the legacy they’d like to leave behind. But it also had to contain all the obligatory hits. It also had to sell the band’s latest album, the self-titled Megadeth.

    To make matters worse, Megadeth was Iron Maiden’s opener, which meant the set was cut down significantly in length. Something had to go, and a lot of things did.

    Megadeth’s softer side was not present. No “A Tout le Monde” or “Trust” or any of their 90s alt rock hits. Most of their later discography went unplayed. Other than “Tipping Point”, the most recent song was from 1992 (!).

    Dave Mustaine mentioned that this may be his last time touring in Australia. I wasn’t aware of this—Megadeth, technically, is finished. The band will disband after this final tour.

    But if it’s any consolation, Megadeth breaking up is not the same as another band breaking up.

    It already happened in 2002. Then Dave changed his mind, and here we were, rain drenching our ponchos, with the jarring stop-starts of “Peace Sells” racing through the crowd like a sonic virus. “What do you mean I don’t believe in God? / I talk to Him every day!” Dave Mustaine can’t make up his mind. This recurs throughout Megadeth’s turbulent saga, often to the benefit of fans.

    Yes, he has health issues. Spinal trouble, throat cancer, and Dupuytren’s contracture (which I hope is less agonizing than it sounds). But it’s still hard for me to imagine an event that can take out Megadeth. Dave Mustaine dropping dead? Well, that would prove a small setback, I grant. But surely the band would be back after a few years. Somehow.

    Long live Megadeth. Glad he got to #1 and lived to tell about it.

    Megadeth setlist (typed from memory)

    • Hangar 18
    • The Conjuring
    • Tipping Point
    • Sweating Bullets
    • Tornado of Souls
    • Symphony of Destruction
    • Peace Sells…But Who’s Buying?
    • Holy War…The Punishment Due

    (Looking at the real setlist on Setlist.fm, I got pretty close.)

    Iron Maiden

    Megadeth left, and the stage went dark. A “please respect the band by keeping your phone in your pocket” message filled the stadium screens.

    In retaliation, a dickhead next to me whipped out his phone, set the screen to max brightness, and started defiantly shining it in circles over the crowd, like a prison searchlight.

    I didn’t hope this man had a bad evening. I am above such pettiness. I instead hoped he had a flawed one. An imperfect one. Hopefully Iron Maiden skipped his favorite song or something. That’s what you get, you contemptible weasel.

    We waited in near-darkness for a long time. Iron Maiden’s road crew had an enormous stage setup to assemble, and Megadeth had inconsiderately left 4×12 Marshall stacks all over the stage.

    Then it was time for the Run For Your Lives World Tour.

    This tour was advertised as a showcase of the band’s history up to Fear of the Dark. A more accurate description would be “Iron Maiden’s discography from Iron Maiden to Seventh Son of a Seventh Son…plus the 1993 song “Fear of the Dark” as an encore.” I guess they ran out of words on the poster.

    The evening was focused like a laser on Iron Maiden’s first seven albums. Their classic run, this contains the work that built their name and fame, and likely most of the songs fans want to hear. The band also brought out a deeper cut or two. We heard “Infinite Dreams”, which Bruce Dickinson stated was being performed for the first time ever in Australia.)

    (Then he shamefully fact-checked himself. “…well, aside from yesterday, when we did it in Melbourne.” )

    I wonder, what will Iron Maiden do next? The logical next step is a “Walk For Your Lives” tour—a 3.5 hour stage show focusing on their recent albums. Can’t wait. I wonder which two songs they’ll play?

    Ha. They have long songs. Got their ass. That wasn’t just a terrible joke, it was a non-fan’s terrible joke. It’s like joking about David Bowie and coke, or the Beatles and Ringo. Making that joke confirms that you are “outside the room”. A dullard who sees only the surface of things. A driveling pajock knave who looks at the night sky and sees just a bunch of glowing dots.

    So let me deny allegations that I am a lightweight. I am a big Iron Maiden fan who is highly knowledgeable. I just love their mascot, Jack Skellington. Man, why does their singer sound so different on the first two albums? Did he have a cold or something? And what’s the deal with “The Number of The Beast”? I don’t want to alarm anyone but I think the lyrics have Satanic implications.

    Anyway, here was the setlist.

    (from tape) Doctor Doctor (UFO)
    (from tape) The Ides of March

    • Murders in the Rue Morgue
    • Wrathchild
    • Killers
    • Phantom of the Opera
    • The Number of the Beast
    • Infinite Dreams
    • Powerslave
    • 2 Minutes to Midnight
    • Rime of the Ancient Mariner
    • Run to the Hills
    • Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
    • The Trooper
    • Hallowed Be Thy Name
    • Iron Maiden

    Encore:
    (from tape) Winston Churchill’s Speech

    • Aces High
    • Fear of the Dark
    • Wasted Years
      (from tape) Always Look on the Bright Side of Life (Monty Python song)

    It was interesting to note which album’s stocks were riding high or low.

    1981’s Killers and 1982’s The Number of the Beast got heavy workouts, with three songs apiece. 1980’s Iron Maiden and 1988’s Seventh Son of a Seventh Son (traditionally something of a “forgotten” album) were represented twice.

    1984’s Powerslave dominated the evening. The band played four songs from it—”Powerslave”, “Aces High”, “2 Minutes to Midnight”, and “Rime of the Ancient Mariner”—note that two of these are lengthy epics. Measured in minutes, between a quarter and a third of Iron Maiden’s set was the Powerslave show.

    Other albums were losers. One song off 1983’s Piece of Mind. No songs at all from 1990’s No Prayer for the Dying (fine by me). “Fear of the Dark” was the only song from the 90s they played. It appeared that Somewhere in Time (another “overlooked” album from their famed classic period) would also be forgotten, until “Wasted Time” brought the curtain down.

    What does Iron Maiden mean to me, and to heavy metal?

    Megadeth is an important band, without which metal would be poorer. Iron Maiden is a foundational band, without which metal would not exist. Or it would exist, but not close to how it exists now.

    What did they give to metal? Grandeur. Storytelling. Even their first album—rough, raw, cheaply produced, a label clearly positioning them as a punk rock band—they have a bigness and ambition. You don’t get many Edgar Allan Poe-themed songs on a Sex Pistols record.

    Their music is what Lawrence of Arabia is to film. Kitsch, hammy, almost overwhelming in its color and scale. Daunting and slightly draining to experience. They make music that can fill days or weeks or perhaps even lifetimes.

    Yet they have a humble working class ethos. There is no sense that they are smirking at or disrespecting their material, or being ironic about it. They seem to be genuinely stirred and moved by the subjects limned to life, and hope for the same impact on you.

    Some things descend from the angels, others crawl from the mud. A rough band from Leyton, Iron Maiden is the latter. Bruce Dickinson alone has a degree. Dave Murray, Adrian Smith, and Nicko McBrain all dropped out of school. Multiple albums were recorded in Steve Harris’s goddamn barn out in Essex.

    But even the humblest Precambrian lifeform might someday sprout wings and fly, and whatever their origins, Iron Maiden have ascended to the stars. They’re a good example of conservative art. They have the same desire to explore life and death and meaning (through history, and poetry, and film) as JRR Tolkien and CS Lewis did.

    (This is one reason why 90s Maiden loses me—suddenly there’s a lot of social commentary, much of it trite and small, Cheap shots at easy targets, like tabloids and televangelists and football hooligans. It’s as if an angel tried to rip off its wings and crawl around in the mud for a while.)

    On a musical level, they are one of the most heavily imitated bands of all time. The choppy harmonized guitars of modern melodic hardcore and related genres is straight from Iron Maiden (or via the scenic route from Sweden’s In Flames, who got it from Iron Maiden.)

    The harmonized guitars. The “gallop”. The blurring of duties between rhythm and lead guitar, between bass and treble clef. The sky-riving high notes. Then there’s the “Iron Maiden album structure”—start on a fist-pumping crowd-pleaser, end on a grand epic—which is obviously not theirs, but so associated with them in heavy metal that it may as well be.

    Bassist and primary songwriter Steve Harris is an astonishingly active musical presence, just as prominent as the dueling leads of Adrian Smith and Dave Murray (and Janick Gers). (And yes, the lion-haired Harris did his “drop to one knee and fire his bass like a machine gun trick” frequently—and each time, cheers filled the air.)

    Iron Maiden and Megadeth feel a generation apart. Megadeth seems like TNG to Iron Maiden’s TOS: the sort of band that would only form after Iron Maiden breaks up.

    Yet…this isn’t true at all!

    They existed at the same time, did they not? Iron Maiden’s recording career began just a few years prior. They were both at the peak of their creative firepower at the same time.

    Maybe it’s because although Iron Maiden clearly inspired all of heavy metal (for Metallica they’re particularly important—the layered clean guitars of “Fade to Black” and the progressive nature of “Call of Ktulu” are obviously built off an Iron Maiden chassis), this influence never went the other way. Iron Maiden was never inspired by heavy metal.

    For fifty years they stuck to their cloud, ignoring the trends scarring and shaping the soil around them.

    Metal drummers (starting from 1983 or so) began using twin bass drums, but Nicko McBrain has used one for his entire career (aside from a one-off experiment on Dance of Death.) The “guitar shredding” hysterics of the mid-late 80s (pinch harmonics, sweep-picked arpeggios, Floyd Rose abuse) never appeared in Murray and Smith’s repertoire. The band has resolutely stuck to standard tuning (aside from Janick Gers, who I believe “drop tunes” to DADGBE).

    Iron Maiden has ignored basically every trend in popular music. Yes, there were synth guitars on Seventh Son and a rawer approach in the 90s (I understand this was a concession to a restless Bruce Dickinson, rather than an attempt to court grunge or alt rock markets as such.)

    This has made Iron Maiden timeless. Suspended in cryonics while the world ages past them. This immunity to style and fashion has aged them extremely well, giving them a margent-encrusted stateliness and antiquity. Age has not rusted their metal, merely dulled it to a beautiful pale-green patina.

    Bruce Dickinson was a fantastic frontman on the night. Just astonishing. It became clear to me that Iron Maiden simply won every lottery at once when they hired him.

    This 68-year-old man charged around the stage all night long—interacting with props, changing costumes, doing pantomimed performances (he’s a frustrated theater kid at heart!), all while nailing piercing high notes written for someone fifty years younger.

    The first two screams in “Killers” were maybe flat, but the third sounded dead-on. And again, my ability to hear high notes was compromised. (I will say that the mix sounded far better during Iron Maiden’s side of the bill, with the lead guitar interplay having a real sensitivity.)

    Between songs, he charmed the crowd with patter. ribbing the guys who’d paid for seats. (“Are you lot alright up there? Under your big concrete umbrella?”) Bruce Dickinson is both erudite and charismatic, introducing each song as a thematic experience in a way that perfectly set the tone. Bruce Dickinson did not steal the show. He earned it fair and square.

    The overall presentation of the show was dazzling. The overhead screens displayed a mix of Derek Riggs’ timeless art, somewhat less timeless CGI animation, and terrible AI slop that looked like TikTok ads for scam games where you save a guy from the lava.

    Rain fell in thick, suffocating sheets. Those with ponchos and plastic sheets hugged them closer. Those without stamped and thrashed and headbanged to stay warm.

    As the pit drowned, Dickinson remarked that it was an appropriate time for “Rime of the Ancient Mariner.” “Water water everywhere, and not a drop to drink.” Apparently, if you are a heavy metal band, there are worse things you can do than write a song about adverse weather!

    (I disagree with Bruce. There is water you can drink. It’s called “Stadium Water” and costs $6 for a tiny bottle but you can definitely drink it, if you are so inclined.)

    As the show neared its end, I was wet and cold. When the stage went dark, I decided it was over, and began to make my way out.

    Whoops. Encore time. I decided to still leave. Luckily, the queue out of the General Admissions pit was crowded. I got to hear “Aces High”, “Fear of the Dark”, and “Wasted Years” on my way out of the stadium, onto Moore Park Rd beyond.

    Adrenaline kept me awake until 3:00am.

  • Obsession

    Obsession

    I finally saw Obsession.

    Months ago, it was a huge, huge hit. A gigantic shadow, raring on the wall. Hard to tell with shadows, though. Sometimes they’re cast by a moth, batting against a light.

    Obsession is a 7/10 movie. In fact, it is 7/10, The Movie: the most 7/10 movie ever made. It is seven and then a dot and then as many zeroes as we can calibrate.

    It packs a whallop. It’s scary and tense and charming. But it will be interesting to see the legacy it ages into—already, few people seem to talk about it. Maybe there’s not much to say.

    The plot is minimal—a “be careful what you wish for!” story very similar to many Goosebumps books, and Are You Afraid of the Dark, and The Monkey’s Paw. (The director claims to have been inspired by The Simpsons’ Treehouse of Horror II. An interesting fact about the future is that culture is now in the hands of people whose main exposure to iconic stories is in the form of parodies of those stories—I suspect we’ve hit a crossover point where people are more familiar withShrek than the fairytales it’s laughing at.)

    It’s hard to describe Obsession’s plot without spoiling it. It’s hard to watch the first ten minutes of Obsession without spoiling it. In a first-ever occurrence, it’s hard to imagine the events the Obsessions’s plot might involve without spoiling it.

    The writing and directing are serviceable. Inde Navarette carries the movie quite hard. Her face seems to be wired up with additional muscles that the rest of the population does not have.

    Why Has It Made Eleven Trillion Dollars?

    The horror genre has spawned many a sleeper hit, but they’re usually not inexplicable sleeper hits. There’s typically an obvious reason why a given popular horror movie is popular. This is not true for Obsession.

    It is not formally innovative like The Blair Witch Project, not the beneficiary of a hot new distribution medium like The Evil Dead, wasn’t helped by a moral panic like Cannibal Holocaust and The Last House on the Left, and will probably will not be remembered as a major example of a film movement like Suspiria. It is distinctive in its unremarkability. So why has it become so popular?

    A Backlash Against Prestige Horror?

    “Prestige horror” refers to the recent surge of horror movies that have (relatively) high budgets, famous actors, cold blue/gray/sepia color-grading, and a lack of fun. Prestige horror desires respectability. It despises and repudiates any connection to “low culture” things like pulp, grindhouse, VHS rentals, porn, or Youtube (except to condescend to them, and show it’s above such tawdry fare). Prestige horror has tense, almost angry aspirations toward being serious art or social commentary.

    Quoting from Will Sloan’s review of Helloween Kills:

    In recent years (since approximately the release of Get Out), the idea that horror movies can be used to smuggle serious sociopolitical ideas has reached a new level of popularity. As a result, the new Halloween movie climaxes with Jamie Lee Curtis delivering a monologue about how Michael Myers represents the fear that divides society and turns people against each other. That’s right, folks. Michael Myers is partisanship. Michael Myers is horseshoe theory. Michael Myers is Donald Trump and Jeremy Corbyn and the Berniebros and the Capitol rioters. Putting aside how stupid it is, her monologue says a lot of things that are better left unstated, because the thing about metaphors is that they’re supposed to be metaphors. If a character in a Halloween movie starts saying that Michael Myers is a symbol of the fear that turns society against itself, the proper response from another character would be, “Actually, no – he’s a masked man who’s quite literally on a killing spree right now.”

    Aside from this, I personally find it a bummer—almost like artistic gentrification—when Hollywood moves in on scrappy, low-budget genres. To me, this “uptown” approach often loses the rampaging energy that makes the genre appealing to begin with. Great horror films generally feel like a pitbull raging at the end of a leash—a force so malign that even the director seems barely in control of the snapping teeth and bulging muscle.

    Perhaps others are sick of prestige horror too.

    Obsession feels like an anti-prestige horror film. Its budget is small, its actors are or were unfamous, and its aspirations are quite humble. It doesn’t want to change your life. It wants to entertain you for a little while and then let you go. It’s the opposite of Inde Navarette’s character.

    But there are other recent trends that Obsession avoids, to its credit.

    It’s slow-paced. It’s not an unhinged gorefest or an alienating exposition of “style”. It’s not the You can watch it without thinking about its artistic forerunners, because it basically doesn’t have any.

    It feels the way watching a movie did when you were a child, and had little connection to culture. When you were an island, in other words.

    But just as a Sentinelese islander who finds a coke bottle is now in contact with an international global brand, Obsession does gesture at some interesting ideas.

    Unconditional Love is Evil

    If someone says they love you unconditionally, there might be hope. They could be lying. Or maybe you misheard them.

    Love with no conditions is evil and abject and monstrous. And it’s also meaningless. Nobody is worthy of that love, and nobody should want it.

    Most people who value it have not internalized just how.

    You are not thinking about what unconditional implies: love without any conditions at all.

    The unconditional lover doesn’t care about you. They assign you no personal subjectivity. They don’t particularly love you for any reason.

    Their love is an alien force that has no connection to anything in the real world.

    Imagine a person whose adoration is so unchanging that they wouldn’t care if you punched them in the face. Or murdered their pet dog. Or tattooed the entire text of Mein Kampf on your face in really small print and didn’t shake your head even once to show the tattooist you disagreed with it.

    An unconditional lover would discover that you have a pile of murdered people in your basement…and they wouldn’t care at all.

    Would that love mean anything? As the recipient, would you value it?

    It goes further: imagine devotion so total that they wouldn’t even care if you died. Their love is not for you, it’s for the pile of atoms you consist of, and they’d be just as happy to love your dead and rotting corpse (and, presumably, the dirt under your body that soaks in your residue) as your living self. Hell, they might even murder you. Why the hell not? If their love could be impacted by trivial distractions like “alive” or “dead”, it wouldn’t be unconditional.

    Obsession is clearly aware of these ideas.

    To an unconditional lover, there is no difference between a living, purring cat and a bag of stinking, matted fur, its blind eye sockets boiling with worms.

    He reacts with revulsion. He might have loved the cat.

    He doesn’t matter to her. His wishes do not matter. He could punch her in the face and she’d still love him.

    Whatever lives in “Frikki’s” demon-doll face, it is not love.

    Conditionality gives love its power. It’s not a foregone necessity for two lovers to stay together: they can leave at any time and are choosing not to.

    Is The Protagonist A Rapist?

    First, the facts.

    The protagonist purchases a supernatural toy called a “One Wish Willow”. He makes a wish on it, forcing a woman (Nicky Freeman) to love him.

    But this is not his original plan. He intends the One Wish Willow as a gift for Nicky. Curry Barker’s original screenplay contains this graf.

    “Bear grabs one. “THE ONE WISH WILLOW. SPARK THE MIDDLE AND BREAK IT IN HALF!” He flips it over. “You only get one wish, so make it count!” Bear smiles; Nicky’s gonna love this.”

    After an awkward interaction with Nicky (she gives him an extremely obvious go-signal, he fumbles it), he’s left stewing in his car, alone. Frustrated by his inaction, he snaps the One Wish Willow in half and makes his own (“half serious”, according to the screenplay) wish.

    I wish Nicky Freeman loved me more than anyone in the fucking world.

    I don’t think this makes him a rapist.

    Because he did not actually think the One Wish Willow would work.

    The world of Obsession is not a fantasy world where wishes come true. It is (apparently) an unmagical one like ours. Bear surely knows that if One Wish Willows granted wishes, they would not be allowed to sell them in stores. They would be tightly controlled by the government, or something.

    “But then why did he make the wish?”

    Because he was blowing off steam. Because he was angry and in pain and needed an emotional release valve.

    The One Wish Willow was not a dastardly plot to control Nikki Freeman’s mind. He just wanted to feel like he was in control for a few seconds.

    A child who stamps their feet and yells “I WISH MOM AND DAD WOULD DISAPPEAR” does not want mom and dad to disappear. Even if, for a few seconds, he thinks he does. It’s emotionally satisfying—if hollow—to enact a fantasy where you have power.

    Nikki kisses him. How does he react?

    “What the FUCK WAS THAT?!”

    …He’s surprised! Shocked! Confused! Because he didn’t expect his wish would work!

    Basically, Bear is in the same situation as a man who gets fired by his boss. He storms out and mutters “I hope an anvil falls on your head, you jerk…” An overly helpful alien overhears him. SPLAT.

    Would we say “the man killed his boss”? Yes, in a sense, he did. But emotionally, we do not regard him as guilty of murder.

    In the same spirit, I do not regard Bear as a rapist.

    Nostalgia For A World Unremembered

    This movie portrays the past.

    Yes, technically all films portray the past: even a livestream of a gamer saying the dreaded N word (meaning “narraag̉iitchuk”, Iñupiat Inuit for “has abdominal cramps”, which as we all know, white people have no right to use, ever) offers a window into the world of a few seconds ago.

    But more seriously, Obsession depicts the unending cultural past that pop culture seems to be stuck in.

    The Simpsons is a perfect example. This is Homer’s car.

    Cars do not look like this anymore. This “three-box” sedan look has gone out of fashion: everyone drives a SUV or a hatchback now. Cars no longer need a big radio antenna. You can listen to the radio via Bluetooth on your phone if you want (which you probably don’t.) Homer’s car is a Plymouth, a brand that hasn’t existed since 2001.

    Notably, the Simpsons is still nominally set in the present day is (mobile phones and so forth exist, as does Lady Gaga). But its stylistic trappings are stuck in the past of 1990 or so. Homer’s car will look like this for eternity.

    Obsession is the same. Despite a few half-assed modern signifiers (a Reddit lookalike, a ChatGPT lookalike, “I don’t wanna get some Karen to…”) everything in it is an artifact from the past.

    • Everything looks retro. The bar is old-fashioned. Bear’s car has roll-down windows. There’s a lunchbox with Polaroid photos inside.
    • the characters work together in…a musical instrument store? That feels like a 90s setting. Today, such stores are mostly dying or dead. Would such a tiny location drum up enough foot traffic to employ a rather large staff of young people with company shirts and so on? People don’t really form bands or play physical instruments. They make music on laptops. Or on Suno.
    • The plot device of young people going out to “grab drinks”, and being passionate about trivia night…while not wrong, it does seem out of step with most of the young people I know. Interests have fragmented down a thousand weird, polarizing rabbit holes, away from public places like sports bars. Bear would be the mod for a Europa Universalis V fan wiki. Nikki would have a femcave where she goons to fujoshi brainrot.
    • The regard One Wish Willows are held in (they don’t work…except maaaaybe they do? Woooo!) feels very “90s”: reminiscent of the days when nobody had internet access and thousands of weird urban legends about the hook handed man could spread by word of mouth.

    It’s an interesting choice how everything is a thing that exists as a pop culture concept, but not necessary as a thing in real life anymore.

    It’s also interesting how the director was born in 1999, meaning he has likely no firsthand memory of the things he’s referencing. It’s all just stuff he saw on TV/movies/Youtube. (Backrooms is an even more extreme example: “liminal horror” and the 90s VHS aesthetic as presented by a 21 year old who was born four months after the creation of Youtube.) Can you feel nostalgia for someone else’s memory? Someone else’s world?

  • Who is japan_nobunaga? An investigative report

    Who is japan_nobunaga? An investigative report

    Everyone, go follow @japan_nobunaga on X.com!

    It’s the funny, whimsical stories of a Japanese person exploring America and learning about their customs! Like salsa chips! And trucks! 🙂

    I just love reading his very real stories which very much happened to a human! 🙂 🙂

    They’re extremely believable. Particularly this one, where he goes to a car wash, pays for the cheapest option, and a rando car wash attendant upgrades him (for no perceptible reason) to premium service while talking like a badly-written NPC in a videogame (“OVERRIDE! UPGRADE HIM TO THE TITANIUM HURRICANE! ON MY DIME!”)

    And I love his adorable art, which (as he explains on his website) is not AI art! (Which just couldn’t match the warmth of hand illustration.)

    I also love his not at all insane-sounding political opinions about immigrants and gay people!

    (This was the only post on the account I could find that wasn’t AI generated.)

    And it’s delightful that his account is based in “Japan”, but has a pesky little warning symbol beside it, indicating that he connects via a VPN.

    And it’s divinely magical that his account has an August 2023 join date, no activity before Nov 14, 2025 (tip, search old tweets using by adding until:2026-01-01 or whatever to the query), and nine username changes. Seems legit. Not at all like he’s a professional marketer who asset-flipped an account through several failed gimmicks until one gained traction. (His earliest public posts appear to be discussions on how to game the X algorithm. They’re in Japanese, which allays my suspicion somewhat. Not completely: it’s odd that he’s so fixated on Trump and US culture war issues. I also wonder how many Japanese people would be comfortable doing an exaggerated, caricatured portrayal of their nation for the edification of borish Americans. I’m Australian. The idea of creating an X.com account called @australian_nedkelly where I pretend to tour America while saying stuff like “blimey, you seppo bastards really call ‘taps’ ‘faucets’, don’t ya? straya, mate. throw another shrimp on the barbie.” makes me want to put the barrel of a gun in my mouth and commit teddy bear picnic)

    Next comes the part we’ve all been waiting for. Where you say one of three things in japan_nobunaga’s defense.

    “1. My urine is green and cloudy”

    You probably have a urinary tract infection. I am not qualified to comment further. Please see a GP.

    “2. He admits the stories are fiction on his website/profile, doofus!”

    He says this:

    These stories are not journalism. They are not realism. They are not a think-piece about America. The samurai is fiction. His misunderstandings are fiction. The diner waitress who calls him “honey” is a composite of every diner waitress who has ever existed.

    There you go! Surely, that’s good enough, right?

    1) His tweets go viral with none of this context included. The average person does not read his website and probably never clicks back to his profile (which contains a vastly different claim anyway, that he uses “AI to polish [his] English” and for research.)

    2) The stories offer no hints that they are fictional. They are written in the first person, in a naturalistic style, and involve everyday events. There are no “winks” to the audience, no pulling back the curtain. The “samurai” does not behave as a samurai would. He’s a “clueless foreigner” stereotype, corny but not unbelievable, and is easily mistaken for the narrator himself.

    3) Even if the writer’s intentions are good (doubtful), most of his audience absolutely does not realize they are reading fake AI slop.

    Here are some replies:

    “Brother, thank you for these posts. If you ever get to Florida let me know, dinner and drinks are on me.”

    “I love your objective view of true American culture and your desire to go beyond observing culture, but to participate in it. “

    “I love the effect that the World Cup is having, bringing us together as good humans regardless of our evil leadership! Here’s a visitor from Japan experiencing free chips and salsa for the first time.”

    This Reddit thread describes his fake truck story as

    “A longer, yet outstanding, tweet by a Japanese man living abroad in the US.”

    The account has received coverage from the withered vestigial organs of the old school printed press, which mainly treat its stories as real accounts.

    Spoon University describes him as “a Japanese tourist” who “shared his experience” of going to a Mexican restaurant.

    The New York Times found the matter so unclear that they DM’d the author for comment.

    Nobunaga, the Japanese wanderer whose reverential written meditations on X about bottomless baskets of chips and salsa at a Mexican restaurant in the United States, isn’t quite what some observers have taken him for, either. He is a pseudonymous character. He isn’t on his way to any World Cup games, either.

    In response to a direct message, Nobunaga’s creator said the premise of the account is that an ancient samurai had traveled through time and space to land in the American heartland. When he wrote that “the trust of a nation is in that salsa, and I intend to honor all of it,” it was meant in a spirit somewhere between parody and cultural commentary.

    4) His “stories” are incredibly boring and pointless if read as fiction.

    “I ate some salsa chips”

    “A guy called Kevin moved my sofa.”

    There is no twist, subversion or element of surprise. They are big bags of nothing. They suck and are dogshit. 100% of their juice comes from the fact that people think it’s a real Japanese person having real experiences.

    “3. But who cares if it’s fake! They’re nice stories!”

    Here are real reactions people have had after realizing they’re huffing Claudeslop:

    “In some ways… I’m OK with that in that the story was a nice story, it resonated with a lot of people and it shows how humanity at one of it’s better sides.”

    “I like your stories. I realize most of them aren’t exactly the truth, who cares? It’s entertainment. Your stories are also very pro-American and down-to-earth…something rare these days. Write on, Samurai.”

    I do not agree that they are nice stories. They are maudlin pap, are written horribly, and they don’t show humanity at “one of it’s [sic] better sides”. They are focused with steely intensity on the classic samurai virtues of consumerism and gorging yourself like a pig on fast food.

    What’s great about America, according to nobunaga?

    – the food is cheap

    – they give you large portions

    – sometimes businesses give you free shit

    – sometimes a guy named Kevin moves your sofa

    The reality that the “free” salsa chips are a loss leader in the Mexican restaurant’s expense account (they are counting on consumers being enticed by free chips to indulge in more expensive, higher-margin items) is lost on the samurai. As is the fact that “Kevin” (if he even exists) is performing reciprocal altruism—today you, tomorrow me. A good practice, to be sure, but he’s hardly doing it out of the kindness of his heart. He’s accruing positive social capital, to be cashed in when he needs help.

    This is saccharine, condescending AI slop, poorly-written by a machine, documenting a dying, decrepit nation trying to cheat death by being too obese to fit into its coffin. They are vapid celebrations of an unworthy life spent rattling like a dry and empty can from one toy to the next. Maybe they are an accurate portrayal of America. This should be a national embarrassment.

    (Also, are they not written in a manner that’s…pornographic? Excessively sensual, etc? “I ate with the gravity the moment deserved. And then — I must report this calmly — the basket emptied, and a new one appeared.” … “By the time my actual food arrived, I was a ruined man. I was not hungry. I was not comfortable. I had been defeated by a courtesy.” I wonder if this is “algo-speak”. Social media won’t allow descriptions of fucking, so we transplant erotic frisson onto things like food.)

    In 2017, HuffPo published a wokescold piece titled “I Don’t Know How To Explain To You That You Should Care About Other People”

    It’s a fine example of vintage 2017 wokescoldery, almost fit for framing in a museum. “I’m done trying to convince these hordes of selfish, cruel people to look beyond themselves.” Great stuff. They don’t make ’em like that anymore. It’s nearly up there with Tommy Needy Drinky.

    Right now, I am feeling “I Don’t Know How To Explain To You That You Should Care About The Truth”.

    When I was a child, I was a compulsive liar. Or at least I had an impulse to fabricate details about myself that made me look cool and important. I would claim to have done things that I hadn’t, to know people that I didn’t. Sometimes I would lie just to fill an awkward silence.

    My internal justification was “It doesn’t hurt anyone, and helps my social life. Who cares about a lie here and there?”

    What changed me (aside from growing up) is that I cared when other people did it to me.

    When someone lied and I caught them, I felt violated and betrayed. Even if the lie was small, I had a hard time getting over it and forgiving them. It was like violently disliked the person who had done it. It was like like reality was a swimming pool, and they’d whipped their dick out and pissed in it.

    And I was doing this to other people. If they ever caught me (and since I was catching other people, it was obviously very much a live possibility), they would probably feel the same about me. And they would be right to do so.

    The account is lying. The internet is awash in AI junk, and a philosophy of “well, this particular incident of lying seems harm-free” is not defensible. I could easily take this in a thousand uncomfortable directions. Nobody is obviously harmed when I claim you owe me money. Or if I claim only five million died.

    To be clear, I would not have a problem if the stories were obviously fictional and fantastical (like if nobunaga drew his blade and practiced Kiri-sute gomen / 斬捨御免, on the car wash attendant, cleansing his ride in filthy commoner blood). But instead they trade on blurring a line between reality and fiction, where he gets to present them as real experiences while rugpulling them as fictions when convenient.

    Maybe they make you feel good, though.